Showing posts with label Comments. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Comments. Show all posts

Saturday, August 3, 2013

The World is Roses: Not Quite

A poster who goes by the name The World is Roses, which is also her blog, has left this comment on my post about Glazov and Ma:
How can we trust YOU not to relay important information about the US to Ethiopia?
I will just re-post what I've already written:
Ma left China around the same age I left Ethiopia. She came to America as an immigrant (legal immigrant, she is happy to inform us). She left China because her parents were looking for better economic prospects. I left Ethiopia because it was a matter of saving my father's life. We were political dissidents. My father was part of the Haile Selassie regime, and he secured a post in the Paris-based UNESCO months before the regime fell apart, and the brutal and vicious dictator Mengistu Haile Mariam took over. Many of my father's colleagues, and friends, were imprisoned. Some were excecuted. This would have probably been the fate of my father.

But, by the grace of God, we ended up in Paris, the most beautiful city in the world! My young years until my late teens were spent between school holidays in Paris, and boarding school in England. My brothers and I got the best of the Western world. We were hardly wealthy. Most of my father's assets had to remain in Ethiopia (and were later confiscated). We lived in cramped apartments. And UNESCO payed the bills for our primary and secondary education. My parents then sent us to college in the U.S. Only one child could secure UNESCOS's college education assistance (which I received, being the eldest), and later, I managed to get a collection of scholarships and grants which took me through graduate degrees.

Soon after we arrived in Europe, we had very little relations with Ethiopia. There were a handful (three of four) Ethiopian families in France since almost all who left Ethiopia had gone to America. I speak Amharic, but my youngest brother barely speaks it. All my post-Ethiopa life has been immersed in the West. But, it wasn't for lack of opportunities that, for me, Ethiopia was in the background. New York and Los Angeles have a huge hub of Ethiopians. When I went to college in the U.S. at seventeen, I could have resumed "where we left off," and started a whole new chapter of "Ethiopianness" with the huge community in New York, but for I opted to stay away from that. I couldn't understand the nostalgic relation to a country which is so far away, culturally, geographically and for me, emotionally.

My blogs and writing will show that I am a unique (odd, some will say) defender of the West, and Western civilization. I have tried to include some Ethiopian elements, primarily its Christian heritage, but that seems to be the only, significant, point of intersection with my Western-oriented work. I have been asked, both in my writings and in my design work, why I don't focus on Ethiopia. Each time, I have ignored those remarks, or made a quick, dismissive reply in order to be left alone. The questions have never been genuine, and were by people who were in some way trying to belittle Western civilization.

And I have been rewarded for my reticence. I have been discovering the extraordinary gifts of Western art and culture since I was a ten-year-old in Paris.

I have maintained this blog (or series of blogs), without any interruption, and without changing my original message and direction, for abut ten years now. And the fruit of that labor is that my writings have enough articles and thought-out arguments that can be published in a book. I hope that will interest, and attract, a much wider scope of people than blog readers.

The book will not be (is not) a "personal" memoir, a la Hirsi Ali, and now Ma, but a theoretical and cultural analysis of art and culture in our West-phobic world, with the aim to reclaim what has been cast aside, and to revive Western culture to the best of my ability, and the best abilities of those whom I hope will join forces with me.

Monday, April 8, 2013

Some Comments and My Responses

Here are my responses to some dense comments (and commentators).

On Churchill introducing the term "Iron Curtain" to the world:
Anonymous: April 8
It's strange that you did not know that Churchill introduced the term 'iron curtain'. It's a very famous fact.
Kidist: April 8
Well yes. And I bet a lot of others did not know that Churchill introduced the term Iron Curtain. Now they know. Now we all know.

That is how knowledge is transferred, but the way. By not making assumptions.

I found it interesting that Churchill introduced it to an American audience, and not a British one.
On the bold Edwardian lady traveler:
Anonymous: April 7
Freya Madeline Stark travelled in the Edwardian era and later, not the Victorian. There is a lot of difference between the Victorian world and the Edwardian world, especially regarding women and attitudes towards their autonomy.
Kidist: April 8
You miss my point on the Edwardian lady travelers vs. the Victorian Lady traveler. I don't see that much difference between the two (see below).

You seem to think "autonomy" is the greatest thing that happened to women. As visceral male reaction shows us, women can get raped for this "autonomy."

Women knew this. They knew that men could protect them, but they could "rape" and destroy them too. Now we have lost that instinct.

But I don't think your point stands. Women doing anything adventurous on their own would have been frowned upon in both societies, and even physically stopped.

And Stark took all kinds of "feminine" precautions, such as getting male leaders on her side through monetary and humanitarian means (she nursed THEIR wounded men!).

Lara Logan would never do this. She strutted along using her sexuality. The result was she got raped.

I have changed the title to the post from Bold Victorian Lady Traveler to Bold Edwardian Lady Traveler.
On where have all the intelligent men gone?
Anonymous: April 8
I am gratified that you chose Gregory Peck and Peter Falk as examples of intelligent men. Did you know that Peck was a lifelong Democrat and very politically active in Democratic and humanitarian causes, not unlike George Clooney ad Brad Pitt? Did you know that he was vocal enough on behalf of those causes that he made Richard Nixon's enemies list? Falk supported Democratic candidates, including Bill Clinton, in elections and gave money to NOW. Peck married working women.

As to Ginger Rogers and being led by Fred Astaire, she used to say that what she did was harder than what he did ... she had to do it backwards, and in heels.
Kidist: April 8
What we have are idiot democrats (i.e. liberals) in our current era hardly compares with the traditional democrats. And yes, Richard Nixon, that paragon of honesty and excellence himself!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted By: Kidist P. Asrat