Friday, November 23, 2018

The Best of East and West

[Updated with links to Asma Arshad Mahmood's postings (KPA October 28, 2022). The original article was on November 2018. I recently discovered the title "Thanksgiving" was posted on Mahmood's website, with a link to my posting here on my long-running website Reclaiming Beauty: Saving Our Western Civilization. I am not sure why she posted it. Perhaps it was to show her followers that she IS indeed "home" in Canada, contrary to my]: 

Apart from the usual "Canada is multiculturalism" and "We're Canadians," non-White immigrants have spent their residence in Canada adapting Canada to the lands they left behind. They were never "home."  ] 
 
I am updating this article, with more current, more detailed information on this clever woman who has convinced the Mississaugan, and Canadian, community that she IS "home" here, even as she left her Pakistani home behind.

I contend that she never did, and that my assessment of four years ago was correct. If anything, Mahmood is even more "back home" in Pakistan than she was a few years ago
. 

Here are my more recent posts on Mahmood, with some updated commentary.

The "Thanksgiving article is linked here (this webpage),  as well as directed via Mahmood's webpage.


1. Art Sabotage (November 9, 2021) - Article excerpt: 

a youngish girl slurping blood through her hand, while holding a goat (a lamb?) on the other.

After the initial horror - blood, and young animals - I realized that this is clearly a "Christian" theme of the Lamb of God, the sacrificial lamb of God, surrounded by a halo, which Mahmood has translated into her own fetish. And hers is a kid (a goat) not the sacrificial lamb that Abraham offered to God.]

2. Traumas and Multiculturalism (May 2, 2022) - Article excerpt:

Mahmood appears in [a] video, where she shockingly reveals how she herself was molested, by unidentified male family member, when she was also a very young girl.

This molestation was known by the family at large, including Abu's wife, but was kept hidden, and quiet, to prevent public humiliations of these seemingly upstanding members of the Pakistani community. 

I wrote of Mahomod's strange paintings, with unidentifiable figures, their faces muted and "hidden."

Surely, this is a reaction to her trauma.

And I wonder in what other ways this trauma manifests itself, besides her frenzied activities to bring "art" to Mississauga: the art and culture she left behind in the country that betrayed her.

This multi-culti depository that Canada has become brings us such people as Mahmood, whose inner turmoils we can only begin to fathom as they are (may be) revealed in discreet confessionals meant for minuscule audiences. I happened to be on of the tiny percentage who caught her words.

I was not wrong about my assessment of her paintings:

Mahmood's paintings are ephemeral sketches of barely-there people.


 












The Art Gallery of Mississauga has sent out a memo to advertise that they are looking for a new curator of contemporary art.
 
The Art Gallery of Mississauga has tried for years now to present the wishful thinking multiculturalism in its programming, and all it has really done is to showcase individual cultures. 

One would think by now that multiculturalism would really be that, multiculturalism: a blend of cultures.

Of course this is not possible. How do blend together Indian, Chinese, various African cultures, Islam, Christianity, Hinduism, etc., etc.?

The fact is that multiculturalism is really appendages onto a historical, traditional culture of the country. There is no blending, but a tenuous coexistence.

There seems to be one contender for this position. 
 
The CBC recently interviewed Asma Arshad Mahmood (which aired in mid-March 2022). Mahmood curated a series of exhibitions which just wrapped at the Art Gallery of Mississauga. The interviewer introduces Mahmood as: "Celebrated Mississauga curator."

Mahmood's four-part exhibition which she titled "...till all are healed," is  on now at the AGM, and works in the series Flowing River, Lotus of Thanks are by local artists whom she asked to paint thanking frontline workers. These works were up for auction to raise money for the pandemic's frontline workers: "to both say a broader thanks and provide income for local artists." 

[...]

The majority of the entries, 20 of the 27 (74%), of the works exhibited were by South Asians, with two white women who have South Asian last names - and are South Asian by extension.

"Lotus of Thanks" is an odd choice for a title. But while Mahmood is Muslim, she interacts with the Indian subcontinent's general culture, where the lotus flower is important (here is a photo of her and her husband after the Hindu festival Holi). 

[...] 
 
So, Mahmood's affiliation to the lotus flower could be for a number of reasons, including to cleverly use its pronunciation to create her message: "Lots of Thanks." 


I went to the 2018 Fine Arts Auction in Mississauga, before the big auction gala (I wasn't willing to pay $80 just to attend). Square One was the locale where the AGM attempted to bring art to the masses (if you have $80, that is), but they cleverly had the works on display about a week before the event, and you could bid online.

I took photos of some works, and also downloaded all the artists' works from various sites (the AGM Facebook page, the auction's ticket purchase page, the auction site, etc.).

Mahmood presented her work Whispers in Theatre, and was also part of the literati that attended the gala.


















The going price for Whispers in Theatre was $800-900, but it doesn't appear to have sold at the auction.

Whsipers in Theatre has that same ephemeral quality that I described in another of Mahmood's piece here as  "an ephemera, a wisp of unidentified/unidentifiable human forms."

But that is neither here nor there. Mahmood has been staking out her territory in Mississauga from way back. She was Board of Director of the Mississauga Arts Council in 2012, but her main activity has been to promote ethnic-based art and culture events which focus on her own background from the Indian sub-continent, going as far back as 2003. 

Mahmood is not new at this. And Mississauga's arts culture is part of her stake out.

5. Recent Developments: The Art Gallery of Mississauga's Annual Benefit Auction - From the Art Gallery of Mississauga's Facebook page:

 
LOT 08
ASMA MAHMOUD (KPA - Spelling?]
Water carriers of Sindh, 2018 Oil on paper
61 x 76.2 cm
Estimate: $800.00 CDN
Have your chance to bid on this piece at the Art Gallery of Mississauga's Annual Benefit Auction
October 26, 2022 | 6:30pm | Small Arms Inspection Building
Buy your tickets now at  bit.ly/AGM35 (link in bio)

 
The same "an ephemera, a wisp of unidentified/unidentifiable human forms," that I described another of Mahmood's work here (also linked to in post 4 above).

And another of the AGM's "...wishful thinking multiculturalism in its programming, and all it has really done is to showcase individual cultures." which I write in post 3 above, with link to article posted here).

This piece is especially evolved. There are no discernible faces, but blobs of oval/circles - eye-openings and niqabed women covering their mouths and noses.

This is certainly part of the reason that Mahmood revived this 4-year-old piece for this auction, since Mississauga's multi-culti residents are all about covering up for this fake-demic, and why not through "art?"

The niqab, which these women are certainly wearing, is described thus:

...a veil for covering the hair and face except for the eyes that is worn by some Muslim women [Source: Merriam-Webster Dictionary]

And the Sindh (administrative unit) in Pakistan:

...the historical home to the Sindhi people is the second most populated administrative unit of Pakistan after Punjab...Sindh is known as Bab-ul-Islam (the gateway of Islam), as it saw the first spread of Islam into South Asia. It has...its roots in one of the world's oldest civilizations, the Indus Valley Civilisation...

Sindh is endowed with coastal access, and is a major centre of economic activity in Pakistan. Karachi, the country's largest city at the southwestern tip of Sindh, is the main financial hub of the country as well one of the most populous cities in the world and has both the country's largest airport and largest seaport. [Source: Wikivoyage]

Mahmood doesn't shy away from updating her Facebook and Twitter pages with the various Islamic holidays that she celebrates (although, with the multi-culti magnanimity of one who have nothing to lose (and has indeed gained a lot) she will reference Christmas with a shiny Christmas Tree and "Happy Holidays." Never Easter, though, that unconditional Christian event. How do you Happy Holidays the cross? Once in a while, the paint-splashing Diwali Hindu holiday appears on her tweets.

And Mahmood is serious about Islam.

Here, in the final installment of this update (below), I discuss Mahmood's connections with her native Pakistan, and where she cleverly uses her influence (it is not as extensive as she and media/cultural outlets make out to be), to program events and collaborations with Pakistan.


Call For Applications:
BNU MDSVAD, in collaboration with Canadian Community Arts Initiative, presents Be(Coming) the Museum, a research-based project that aims to build stronger relationships between creative practitioners and museums in Pakistan. The project is envisioned as a catalyst to inspire emerging artists to build a sense of connection with museums and their historical collections of art and artifacts.
We will also consider the question, "What is the museum of the future?"
Seminar Dates: 5th and 6th November 2022
Deadline to Apply: 26th October 2022
This open call is open to emerging creative practitioners across Pakistan.
For full application details: Link in Bio
Project Partners: BNU SVAD, CCAI, Lord Cultural Resources and Lahore Museum.
This project is lead by @asmamahmood and @shellybahl

About the institutions cited in this announcement:
- Lord Cultural Resources [link]:
Lord Cultural Resources is the global practice leader in cultural sector planning. Since 1981, we have helped to create, plan, and operate cultural spaces and places in more than 460 cities, in 57 countries and six continents. [Source: Lord.ca]
Gail Dexter Lord...co-founded Lord Cultural Resources with her husband Barry Lord in 1981. [Source - Gail Lord LinkedIn]  
Lord Cultural Resources is a Canadian organization, but they are opaque about their financial arrangements. My conclusion is that museums and other cultural organizations obtain governmental funds, which they then use to pay for the museum consultations services provided by Lord Cultural Resources.
- Canadian Community Arts Initiative [link]:
The clever (or finely tuned "multiculturalist") Mahmood the Canadian Cultural Arts Initiative's Board Member and Senior Artistic Director where she "represents the organization on various international forums."
Canadian Community Arts Initiative regularly presents visual arts, literary, dance, theatre, film and other artistic events for the enjoyment and education of the community. CCAI regularly collaborates with artists and organizations to support artistic activities in and around Mississauga and GTA. 
A more interesting description is [link]:

CCAI is a not for profit organization registered under the laws of the province of Ontario to promote effective role of arts and artists in Canadian community.
 
And especially this part:

CCAI aims to enhance the community's awareness of the many arts and cultural practices in Canada and encourages expansion of the arts by creating opportunities for practicing local artists.
 
What does "local artists" mean? What are "the many arts and cultural practices in Canada"?

These are code words for "multiculturalism."  Mahmood uses her Pakistani influence in Canada, as well as expanding it ("expansion" from her CCAI description) to her native Pakistan. Conveniently, she identifies herself as Canadian/Pakistani. But Pakistan is the core of her activities.
   
And all this leads to:

- BNU MDSVAD - Beaconhouse National University Mariam Dawood School of Visual Arts & Design - Lahore Pakistan, Mahmood's current, perhaps most important, project in Pakistan (and in Canada), where a variety of Canadian monies are used to fund a project, a NATIONAL, Pakistani, project, in Lahore Pakistan.

This might yet be Mahmood's Swan Song. I thought previously she was vying for the AGM's director position in the future. But I doubt it. She is too old to scuffle with the multi-culti-literati of Mississauga, young or youngish hyphenated-Canadians; Arabs, Chinese, Blacks, and her fellow non-Muslim Indians.

She has come full circle, getting the best of all worlds: living in a Western society, with all its moneys, expertise, modern systems, and creativity, to shuttle back and forth to her native Pakistan to assist in building its institutions. All at her schedule, and all fees paid.

Lahore Museum, Lahore, Pakistan
This image is also on the Facebook page "Asma Mahmood" which Mahmood has used for the poster to announce the "open call" for applicants for this grant. 

-----------------------
This is the original article posted here, as well as linked to via Asmamahmood.com

Apart from the usual "Canada is multiculturalism" and "We're Canadians," non-White immigrants have spent their residence in Canada adapting Canada to the lands they left behind. They were never "home."

And, these many years later, they realize that they have FAILED in building this "home."

So what are they going to do about it?

Here is a "South Asian" couple which lives a seemingly "westernized" life in the Mississauga area. But they never mentioned the Canadian Thanksgiving holiday this past October 8th on their otherwise prolific Facebook sites.


Arshad and Asma Mahmood
Celebration Square, before of the Mississauga City Hall
TD (Toronto Dominion Bank) Mosaic Outdoor Festival, August 2018
Posted in Facebook


The couple posts extensively on Mosaic - The South Asian Festival of Mississauga, and in the photo above, they are in front of Mississauga's City Hall, before a full crowd which came out for the Mosaic festival on the Celebration Square mall, in August 2018.

The Mosaic Festival of Mississauga, with a major sponsorship by the Toronto Dominion Bank of Canada,
brings together South Asian and Fusion dance, music, and art performances in a mosaic of culture and talent. The two-day event features both local and international acts...
Here's what Arshad Mahmood posted this past October 8 (Thanksgiving):


And Asma Mahmood, an artist who participated in the April 2018 Fine Art Auction by The Art Gallery of Mississauga, and not as prolific a Facebook poster as her husband, also made no mention of Thanksgiving. But she did "update" her Facebook photo a couple of days later, on October 11.




Asma Mahmood
Whispers in theatre, 2018
Acrylic on canvas board
29.9 ins x 24 ins 76 cms x 61 cms
Auction work
Estimate: $800–900


Below is an excerpt from an interview in View the Vibe of the couple, and how they founded the Mosaic festival in 2006.

This year's event took place on August 3 and August 4, 2018
...Arshad and Asma Mahmood decided it was high time Mississauga had more high-profile arts and cultural events that reflected the backgrounds and interests of the city’s inhabitants. Along with a group of like minded friends they established the Canadian Community Arts Initiative (CCAI), and, soon after, Mosaic, a SouthAsian multidisciplinary arts festival, was born [in 2006].
[Source: Tastemakers: Ashad and Asma Mahmood, View the Vibe Magazine, July 21, 2014
From TD Mosaic web page:
Mosaic is supported by the City of Mississauga and has received funding from Department of Canadian Heritage, Ontario Trillium Foundation, Province of Ontario, Ontario Arts Council and Toronto Tourism.